Personally, I think it is very wrong of the church. I believe the bible says, "baptize people".....etc. It doesn't say, "force people to become members of churches." Is there a reason why she doesn't want to become a member? At the church I got baptized at, they don't require church membership, but rather make it an option.

Becoming a member/joining a chruch is 2 different things from following Christ.

:rolleyes: Interpret it as you wish. In *reply* to your post, no, it was not an incomplete sentence. No more incomplete than it would be irl conversation *in reply* to your comment/s. Had I started a thread stating *just* that question *or* replied w/o including your comment, then yes, "Just Catholics?" would make no sense. But if it makes you feel better to nitpick, okay *shrug*.